What is a Clarifying Lesson?
A model lesson teachers can implement in their classroom. Clarifying Lessons combine multiple TEKS statements and may use several Clarifying Activities in one lesson. Clarifying Lessons help to answer the question "What does a complete lesson look like that addresses a set of related TEKS statements, and how can these TEKS statements be connected to other parts of the TEKS?"
TEKS Addressed in This Lesson
Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning: 5.2A, B, C; 5.4A, B
Probability and statistics: 5.12A, B; 5.13C
Underlying processes and mathematical tools: 5.14A, B, C, D; 5.15A, B; 5.16A, B
Materials
- assorted books and magazines
- craft paper
- pens and markers
- calculators
Related Resources
A Collection of Math Lessons From Grades 3 Through 6 by Marilyn Burns
OLD Resources. The resources on this page have NOT yet been updated to align with the revised elementary mathematics TEKS. These revised TEKS were adopted by the Texas State Board of Education in 2005, with full implementation scheduled for 2006–07. These resources align with the original TEKS that were adopted in 1998 and should be used as a starting point only.
Clarifying Lessons
Grade 5: Alphabet Frequency
Lesson Overview
Students explore the frequency with which the letters of the alphabet are used in the English language.
Mathematics Overview
Students collect and organize data from writing samples, use fractions and decimals to describe the experimental data, and use the experimental results to make predictions about the frequency of letter usage in the English language.
Part 1
Set-up (to set the stage and motivate the students to participate)
- Have students brainstorm situations when it is important to know how
frequently letters are used (e.g. designing a game like Scrabble; playing
Wheel of Fortune; designing packages of punch-out or rub-off letters; solving
cryptograms; and designing keyboards.) (5.14A)
- Ask students what five
letters they think are used most frequently in the English language.
Students should then discuss their individual predictions in their groups
and prepare a group prediction.
- Next, have each small group design a
plan to test their predictions. Use guiding questions to help each group
include in their plan collecting a sample of data (e.g. counting the
number of each letter used in a paragraph from the newspaper) and organizing
their data into a frequency table or graph. (5.13C; 5.14B, C, D)
- Have
each group use fractions and decimals to describe their data. (5.2A,
C; 5.4A, B; 5.12A, B; 5.15A)
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Guiding Questions (to engage students in mathematical thinking during the lesson)
- What did your group decide to do to test your prediction about the most frequently
used letters in the English language? (5.14B, C, D)
- Why did you decide to
do that? (5.14B, C, D; 5.16B)
- Where did you decide to get your sample of
data? Why? (5.14C, 5.16B)
- How did you decide to record your data? Why?
(5.14B, 5.14D, 5.16B)
- How did you decide to organize your data? Why?
(5.13C, 5.14D, 5.16B)
- How can you use fractions to describe your data?
(5.2A, B; 5.12A; 5.15A)
- How can you use decimals to describe your data?
(5.2C; 5.4A, B;5.15A)
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Summary Questions (to direct students' attention to the key mathematics in the lesson)
To encourage students to analyze and evaluate their plans for testing their predictions about letter frequency, ask questions such as:
- How did you decide to test your predictions about letter frequency? (5.14B,
C, D)
- Why did you use the sample of data that you did? (5.14B, 5.16B)
- How did you organize your data? (5.13C, 5.14C, D)
- What other ways might you have organized it? (5.13C, 5.14C, D)
- Why did you decide to organize it the way you did? (5.13C, 5.14C,
5.16B)
- What observations can you make from your data organized the
way it is? (5.12B, 5.16A)
- What observations might you be able to make
from it if it were organized another way? (5.12B, 5.16A)
- Based on
your data, what is the order of the letters according to frequency of
use? (5.12B, 5.16A)
- Are all the groups' results the same? If not, how
are they different? Why do you think they are different? (5.15A)
To highlight the use of fractions and decimals to describe the results, ask questions such as:
- How can you use a fraction to describe the frequency of the use of the
letter n based on your data? (5.12A; 5.15A, B)
- How can you use that fraction
to compare your results to someone else's results? (5.2A, B)
- How can you use a decimal to describe the frequency of the use of the
letter n based on your data? (5.2C; 5.4A, B; 5.15A, B)
- How can you
use that decimal to compare your results to someone else's results?
(5.2C; 5.4A, B)
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Part 2
Set-up (to set the stage and motivate the students to participate)
- Have students discuss why they think the lists of frequencies determined
by each group are not exactly the same. Discuss the use of larger samples
upon which to base decisions.
- Have students enter each group's totals
into a class chart (on craft paper). For example,

Use three different colors of markers (for instance red, green, and black), alternating colors (red, green, black, red green, black, etc.) for the letters in the headings of the chart. Ask students to record their totals in the same color that the letter it pertains to is written in. (This makes the chart much easier to read from a distance.) (5.14C)
- To avoid traffic jams, ask half of the groups to start at "a" and work
towards "z" and half of the groups to start at "z" and work towards "a". (5.14C)
- As groups finish, assign letters to them so they can find the class totals.
Discuss the need for more than one person to do the totals to make sure
that they are accurate. (5.14C)
- After all the totals have been calculated
and entered, have students use the data in the chart to identify the
letters in order of frequency. (Students may want to reorganize the data
to be able to see this more clearly, e.g. enter it into a spreadsheet
and make an ordered list or a bar graph.) (5.14D; 5.15A, B)
- Have students
use fractions and decimals to describe the frequency of each letter
in the class sample. (5.2A, B, C; 5.4A, B; 5.12A, B; 5.15A, B)
- Have students
compare the class results to their individual group results and to "official" letter
frequency lists. (5.15A; 5.16A, B)
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Guiding Questions (to engage students in mathematical thinking during the lesson)
- How can we represent the class data most efficiently? (5.13C; 5.14B, C, D)
- How can we organize and represent the class data to see how it compares
to the groups' data? (5.13C; 5.14B, C, D; 5.16A)
- How can we use the chart to analyze the class data? (5.13C; 5.15A)
- How can we use fractions to describe the class data? (5.2A; 5.15A,
B)
- How can we use decimals to describe the class data? (5.2C; 5.4A, B;
5.15A, B)
- How can we use fractions to compare the class data to the groups' data?
(5.2B; 5.15A, B)
- How can we use decimals to compare the class data
to the groups' data? (5.2C; 5.4A, B; 5.15A, B)
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Summary Questions (to direct students' attention to the key mathematics in the lesson)
To encourage students to analyze the class data about letter frequency, ask questions such as:
- What order of letter frequency does the class data indicate? (5.12B, 5.15A)
- Which representation of the data makes this easiest to see? (5.13C, 5.15A)
- How does this order compare to that shown by each groups' data? (5.15A)
- Why do you think the class order is different from some of the group
orders? (5.12B, 5.16B)
- Which order do you think is the most reliable
to use in making predictions? Why? (5.12B, 5.16B)
- When taking a
survey, how would you decide how many and which people to ask? Why? (5.12B,
5.14A, 5.16B)
- How can the way you collect your sample influence your
results? (5.14A, B, 5.16B)
- What kinds of things in our data collection
about letter frequency might have influenced our results? (5.14B,
5.16B)
To highlight the use of fractions and decimals to describe the results and make predictions, ask questions such as:
- How can you use a fraction to describe the frequency of the use of the
letter n based on the class data? (5.12A; 5.15A, B)
- How can you use fractions
to compare the frequency of n based on the class data and the frequency
of n based on your group's data? (5.2A, B; 5.15A, B)
- How can you use a decimal to describe the frequency of the use of the
letter n based on the class data? (5.2C; 5.4A, B; 5.15A, B)
- How can
you use decimals to compare the frequency of n based on the class data
and the frequency of n based on your group's data? (5.2C; 5.4A, B;
5.15A, B)
- What is an advantage of reporting the results in the form
of fractions and decimals? (You can compare results from different
sizes of data samples.) (5.15A, B)
- So, in designing a set of 250
rub-on letters, how could you use the fraction descriptions of
letter frequency to help you decide how many of each letter to include?
(5.12B; 5.14A, B, C, D)
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Assessment Task(s) (to identify the mathematics students have learned in the lesson)
- Have each student write a report, explaining the process they used for
collecting and organizing data and using fractions and decimals to describe
their results.
- Give students a set of fractions or decimals that describe
a hypothetical set of data, and ask them to describe what the data could
have looked like.
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)
Extension(s) (to lead students to connect the mathematics learned to other situations, both within and outside the classroom)
- Students can make up sentences such as "This is odd. Do you know why? Try
to find out. Do you know now?" that do not fit their results of letter frequency.
- Students can play the "You Can't Say N" game. One person starts to talk,
trying not to say any word with the letter n in it. Others in the group
listen. When the person talking uses a word with an n, someone else tries.
- Students can research the development of the QWERTY keyboard and its relationship
to letter frequency. Students can use their results to design a keyboard
and justify their design.
- Students can investigate the game of Scrabble.
They can list the letters in the game in two ways—in order of their
values and in order of how many there are of each. Then can then make conclusions
about how Scrabble relates to their letter frequency findings and why
they do or do not think the Scrabble scoring or the quantity of any letter
should be changed.
- Students can conduct a letter frequency study for languages
other than English and compare their results.
- Students can use
the class results to solve a cryptogram.
Teacher Notes (to personalize the lesson for your classroom)